Skip to main content Skip to footer

The Old Grist Mill

Based on 5 reviews
created by Susanne Sholander
sample tin
makes 5 cups
3oz pouch
37¢ per cup
5oz tin
38¢ per cup
A hint of smoke from the oil of Edelwood trees, and those beatiful (tiger) eyes--could it be the beast? An inclusion of sprinkles serves as a candy trail to guide you back home. Dark and mysterious like the woods, this blend will lure you in with its rich savory flavor mixed with the subtle sweetness of chocolate and caramel.

High caffeine | Steep at 212° for 3 minutes.
Signature blends are not eligible for returns.

Customer Reviews (5)

ingredients & lore

blended with black tea, yunnan jig tea, wuyi ensemble tea, lapsang souchong, natural caramel flavor, cocoa nibs, natural chocolate flavor & natural vanilla flavor

tea puddle tea puddle tea puddle

teas: lapsang souchong, mambo & tiger eye

accented with sprinkles

Inspired by Chapter 1 of Over the Garden Wall.
blend image

this blend is in a 'ship

The Old Grist Mill has hooked up with Hard Times at the Huskin Bee.
Let their love steep in your cupboard and get 10% off when you purchase both 3oz pouches.
Hard Times at the Huskin Bee
3oz pouch

this tea is part of the OVER THE GARDEN WALL fandom

fandom band
Love The Old Grist Mill? This is just one of 10 teas in this fandom. Check out the whole series.

create the perfect fandom gift box

Now's your chance to create your very own custom fandom sampler set! Select six samples of your favorite blends from any collection and we will create a box set unique to you.

tin design
tin design tin design tin design tin design tin design tin design tin design
Ask us a question.
Adagio Chatbot
You may ask me "Where is my order?" or "How much is shipping?" and I will gladly answer your question.
If you don't like my answer, our customer support team will email you a reply shortly. Ask me!