★★★★☆
The tea had a strong key lime aftertaste, which wasn't really my thing.
We've recreated the bliss of Key Lime Pie in a playful herbal blend for sunset celebrations, a la Conch Republic.
Customers use these reviews to describe their experience with Key Lime Herbal, including flavor, aroma, preparation preferences, strength, and how the tea fits into daily routines. Browse the full review history page by page to compare tasting notes, steeping tips, and favorite ways to enjoy this tea.
The tea had a strong key lime aftertaste, which wasn't really my thing.
A very light pleasant tasting tea, with a subtle essence of lime. Refreshing. I enjoyed it, you will too if you want something different.
This tastes exactly like you d expect! This is liquefied key lime pie!
It’s not that we didn’t like this tea, it’s just that it was a little like kool aid and wasn’t strong on the key lime flavor. I brewed this as iced tea. It comes out red. I wonder—had we not seen the color, would we have tasted more lime??
I can taste a slight lime taste to this tea. It’s refreshing!
Worth the wait. I enjoyed this tea very much!
This tea was really surprising. I expected a light and citrus flavor, but it’s SO MUCH BETTER! Awesome as an ice tea!
This tea was lovely. It reminded me very much of key lime pie, and smells wonderful as it brews.
A refreshing hot and iced tea. Has just the right citrus flavor!
Sweet and refreshing with just a hint of tart. It smells exactly like limes and is pleasantly sweet. A little honey enhances the lime and makes it a true key lime pie. It pairs exceptionally well with the Berry Creme Compote creating an even better tea. It has a reminiscent feel of the Sonic Cherry Limeades, I am sure if you were to blend it with a cherry tea you could recreate that same taste. Overall very good. The first steep is intense the second pleasant and the third is week. After, three steeps there is no flavor left. This also blends well with Snowbud and White Symphony making it a tea with actual tea leaves.
Very nice! Summery, bright herbal tea. If anything, I wish had had even stronger lime flavor.
Bright lime flavor. Great iced.love it!
Summertime must have!
Really good summer time flavor, I will be purchasing this in the future.
Tastes just like a key lime pie! Drank it over ice with a bit of honey
Yuck! This tea is kind of gross. The key lime flavor is very fact and the tartness of the other parts of the tea are super offputting.
Key Lime Herbal is a very nice summer tea. It's light and taste great!
Very tasty, I could be forgiven for thinking it was a fancy, not full of sugar kool-aid when made with the cold brew method.
This is another one that we cold steep for iced tea. I ve gotten samples of this before, but this time I went all in and I have to say I m glad I did.
Tastes just like key lime pie. Nice fruity flavor.
I'm not a huge fan of key lime, but my boyfriend is, and he loved this tea! We tried it hot, but I'm sure it would be just as good cold.
This tea is wonderful for summer. I made some and let it cool and added sweetened condensed milk and ice, tastes just like a key lime pie!
Wow! Lime can go either way. Tart and sour or sweet and refreshing. This is the perfect blend that finishes with the taste of Key West in July. LOVE!!!
This tea is kinda nice. It’s a little sweet and tangy. I added lemon and a bit of honey. It taste like key lime pie to me. It smells much stronger dried in the bag but than the taste after steeped. I thought I wouldn’t like it when I first opened the bag the smell was strong But after steeping it’s kinda nice.
I tried this iced and hot and I love this iced! It is perfectly sweet and does not need added sugar!
We made this iced, and really enjoyed it! The flavor is mildly sweet. It is a beautiful red color. My whole family enjoyed this tea.
Love this tea! Pleasantly sweet & tangy, with a good lime flavor.
So disappointing. I love (real) lime flavored things, and key lime pie is my favorite pie. This tasted nothing like limes or pie. The other reviews made this so promising, but this was so terrible I couldn't even finish the cup. I kept taking sips to see if it would get better as it cooled, but by the time I drank about half I couldn't take any more. It smelled like a terrible citrus cleaning product when I opened the bag, and it never got better, even brewed it smelled more like a cleaning product than something you want to drink. And it tasted like someone poured a melted lime otter pops freezer pop in a cup of weirdly fruity tea. So sad that it had such a fake, weird lime flavor.
Really did not think I would like this, but wanted to try it all the same, but was surprised and loved this! The lime is really good in this and now I want a bigger bag! (i cold steeped this)
It has a very sharp citrus flavor, it may take a few to grow on me, just caught me off guard. Most of the time Adagio teas don't taste as strong as they smell...except not this one.
Last year, I cashed in loyalty points for the free bag of this tea. I was initially disappointed with the tea itself, but absolutely went bonkers when I combined this with Calypso Green tea. I like to buy tea based on the season. With summer arriving, I will get to enjoy the Key Lime/Calypso combo all over again. I'm not even waiting for this tea to arrive at my door to write about this. I can't wait.
Not a fan. Expected a brighter flavor, but the lime was muddled by the taste of the herbal base. Would not recommend.
You get more flavor from this via cold brew rather than hot brew. That said, it's a little too tart for my liking, but it does exude that iconic key lime pie flavor.
I'm not a big herbal tea fan, but I love the flavor of lime, and this was enjoyable iced.
The citrus flavor was very strong and too much for me. I end up using just a pinch mixed in with my other herbals to get that 'squeeze of lime' flavor.
Just like pie, very nice iced with a bit of heavy cream.
Unique to my tea stash and does taste like key lime pie! Have to be in the right mood for it.
My fiancee loves lime, so I got her this tea during the summer, and it was a smashing hit! She was actually really upset that I only got the sample and that it was gone so quickly. Sadly I did not get to try the tea myself because she drank it all, but the fact she did not share and demanded that I buy more is a good sign!
This tea is nice and refreshing, it had a stronger lime component than I was expecting. It was a pleasant surprise. I also enjoyed this tea over ice.
I found this to be a very good, soothing, tea. Key Lime pie has always been a favorite of mine, so that aromoa and flavor brings back good memories for me.
Love this!!! Very refreshing - like it all year round
This tea was great iced, but I felt like the flavor was a little too subtle. It smelled more like key lime than it tasted like lime, but maybe I just need to steep it longer. Will definitely order it again to give it a try.
I'm not a fan of herbal teas but this has a lovely, fruity pop that is perfect with dessert.
Too tart, and not very nice taste. I didn't appreciate it.
I was so upset that they took this amazing blend away before the official end of summer. This may easily be my favorite blend ever. The lime is spot on.
My husband isn't much of a tea guy, but when I told him that I was ordering more tea he was like, 'Make sure you get some more Key Lime.' This is a tea that reminds you of dessert. It doesn't taste exactly like pie, but it is tasty and helps satisfy the sweet tooth without the guilt.
This Tea is like eating key lime pie fresh out of oven.
very artificial lime flavor, not my preference, probably won't be ordering again
Very unusual taste. I think I'd like to try it as an iced tea
This was so flavorful! It was a sweet afternoon treat that tasted just like key lime. I put a tiny bit of honey in it.
Not quite what I was expecting. The flavor is missing,